Efficacy of professional flossing, supervised flossing and mouth rinsing regimens on plaque and gingivitis: a 12-week, randomized clinical trial¹

Objective

To evaluate the efficacy of twice-daily alcohol-containing, essential oil mouthrinse (LISTERINE^® Antiseptic) and brushing, and flossing and brushing, under once-daily supervision for the prevention and reduction of plaque and gingivitis.*

_{*Floss is intended to remove plaque and food particles between teeth to reduce tooth decay.}²

Methodology 

Primary endpoints were interproximal mean Modified Gingival Index (MGI) and interproximal mean Turesky Modification of the Quigley-Hein Plaque Index (TPI) at Week 12. Interproximal mean bleeding index (Bl) at Week 12 was a secondary endpoint. 

• All subjects were supervised once daily at the clinic, Monday through Friday. Second treatment of the day, Saturdays, and Sundays at home were unsupervised and recorded in diaries. 

• For all oral examinations, subjects refrained from oral hygiene for 8-18 hours and did not eat for >4 hours before the visit.

Subjects (N=156) were randomized into 4 groups:

_{Inclusion criteria: aged >18 years; good general and oral health; no known allergies to commercial dental products; >20 teeth with scorable facial and lingual surfaces; evidence of gingivitis; >10 bleeding sites based on the Bl; and absence of: fixed or removable orthodontic appliance or removable partial dentures, significant oral soft tissue pathology excluding plaque-induced gingivitis, and advanced periodontitis based on a clinical examination and discretion of the investigator/dental examiner.} 

_{Exclusion criteria: dental prophylaxis within 1 month prior to the Baseline visit; need for antibiotics prior to dental treatment; use of antibiotics, anti-inflammatory or anticoagulant therapy within 1 month prior to Baseline; use of oral care products containing chemotherapeutic anti-plaque/anti-gingivitis products within 2 weeks prior to Baseline; use of smokeless tobacco; and any other medical or psychiatric condition that would make the volunteer inappropriate for the study in the judgement of the Investigator.}

Results

At Week 12, compared with brushing + negative-control mouthrinse, only brushing + LISTERINE® Antiseptic provided statistically significant plaque reduction; and brushing + LISTERINE® Antiseptic, brushing + flossing by hygienist, and brushing + flossing under supervision groups provided statistically significant gingivitis and bleeding reduction. 

• Compared with brushing + negative-control mouthrinse, interproximal and whole mouth plaque were significantly reduced for the brushing + LISTERINE® Antiseptic group, but not for the brushing + flossing by hygienist or brushing + flossing under supervision groups, at Week 12

LISTERINE^® Antiseptic significantly reduced plaque and gingivitis:

_{‡Flossing by dental hygienist. Sustained plaque reduction after a dental prophylaxis.}

_{NOTE: Flossing effectively removes imbedded food particles and biofilm between the teeth, helping improve the health of patients' gums and offering a useful tool in daily oral hygiene. Together, flossing, brushing, and rinsing with LISTERINE® Antiseptic on a daily basis provides a comprehensive approach to oral care and an approach to cleaning that reaches nearly 100% of the mouth.}^2,3

• Compared with brushing + negative-control mouthrinse, interproximal and whole-mouth gingivitis were significantly reduced for the brushing + LISTERINE^® Antiseptic group, as well as for the brushing + flossing by hygienist and brushing + flossing under supervision groups

• Compared with brushing + negative-control mouth rise, interproximal bleeding index was significantly reduced in the brushing + LISTERINE^® Antiseptic, brushing + flossing by hygienist, and brushing + flossing under supervision groups

• To measure bleeding index, a periodontal probe with a 0.5 mm tip was inserted into the gingival crevice and swept about the tooth at approximately a 60-degree angle. Each of four gingival areas (disto-buccal, mid-buccal, mid-lingual, mesio-lingual) was assessed after about 30 seconds. (0=no bleeding; 1 = bleeding after 30 seconds; 2=immediate bleeding.)

Conclusions

• LISTERINE^® Antiseptic yielded larger reductions compared to brushing alone in plaque (TPI) and gingivitis (MGI) than hygienist-performed or hygienist-supervised flossing at Week 12 

• LISTERINE^® Antiseptic, hygienist-performed flossing, and hygienist-supervised flossing all statistically significantly reduced interproximal bleeding at Week 12 compared to negative-control mouthrinse 

• Adding LISTERINE^® Antiseptic to an oral care routine reduced supragingival plaque more effectively than flossing by a dental hygienist 

  • Dental professionals may use these data to recommend the most effective oral care routines to their patients depending on their needs